Tuesday, September 2, 2014

03.00 Introduction To Ethics

There are many situations where it seems there are no good answers, and determining the right response depends on one's code of ethics. However, that raises an important question on a more basic level - what exactly are ethics, and what does it mean to be ethical? To the first, one could say that ethics are a code of honor, of sorts - moral guidelines that people follow, whether or not they are conscious of it.  However, that isn't all there is to it; if someone's moral guidelines told them it was okay to become a serial killer, that would hardly be ethical. So rather, ethics are a specific set of rules that may be hewed to closely or ignored altogether.

So that's where the second question comes in - what does it mean to be ethical? While there is no perfectly defined set of rules, there are many common items that together help to give form to the broad idea. One must be honest, both in the sense of being truthful and in the sense of being trustworthy. Moral behavior -don't steal, don't hurt or kill, don't be a jerk- is also an important part of ethics; the two are closely related, but not exactly alike. And last, another important thing that defines ethical behavior is to be supportive of and considerate to others. Honesty and morality mean little if one still fails to take into account the feelings of others, after all. Sometimes this last directive can also come into conflict with the first two, resulting in an ethical dilemma.

There is a good example of one such dilemma, wherein someone's friend gave their home address to a potentially dangerous stranger. The basic quandary was whether or not to tell the friend's parents about this, but there were many factors that complicated the situation; telling might be a betrayal of the friend's trust and could even lead to further reckless behavior if the parents mishandled the situation, but failing to tell would in and of itself be dishonest to the parents, enabling to the friend, and in the worst-case scenario, may lead to bigger issues if the stranger is in fact dangerous and the family is unprepared.

In this case, it would be important to handle the situation delicately. One approach could be attempting to encourage the friend to tell their parents themselves, or else telling the parents directly, but making clear to both parties that proper communication is important, without simply following their most immediate knee-jerk reactions. If cooler heads can prevail, a resolution to the problem may be found without calamity or further alienation. One would hope their friend could understand why this was done, but so long as they remained safe, it would be okay if they remained angry as well. It can't be said with complete certainty if that is the absolute best way to handle the situation, but one would think that it's along the right lines, maintaining at least some degree of integrity while looking out for the friend's best interests.

There is a third question to consider: how do ethics apply to journalism? First, we will take a brief tangential detour; there is a movie called, "A Town without Christmas." It concerned a child who had written a letter to Santa, implying that they would commit suicide soon. A television reporter was attempting to track them down, both to 'get the story' and try to find help for them. However, upon finally finder her, the reporter faced an ethical conflict; publishing the story could potentially save the child's life, but would also break the promise the reporter had made not to tell anyone about the situation, and would reveal some sensitive private information. That conflict seems like a fairly good example of a potential journalistic ethical dilemma.

To return to the original topic, it could be said that ethics apply to journalism similarly to other situations, but privacy is often a major factor. Since the information is going out to the public, quite a few people will end up seeing or hearing about it, so the question becomes, what should be held back and what should be published, and how much? Do the costs of publishing something outweigh the potential positive effects, or the other way around? Much like with other moral dilemmas, there is no single right answer (though plenty of wrong ones) and the situation must be handled with tact and delicacy. For this reason, many news institutions have a written code of ethics which their reporters must follow, but those can only get one so far before personal intuition is required. Regardless, a good set of ethics are as important in journalism as it is in life in general.

No comments:

Post a Comment